Jump to content
Why become a member? ×

Filling the 'space' in a rock and roll band - help needed...


dazza14
 Share

Recommended Posts

I've recently started a rock n roll band and the band consists of drummer, guitarist, bass and singer, and its going really well but when we play covers from bands with two guitars the music really suffers because the guitarist switches from rhythm to lead leaving me and the drummer trying to fill the space left behind. Because a lot of the songs are walking bass lines it leaves a lot of space, I was wondering if there is an effect I could use to 'fatten' up the bass sound so we don't 'drop' everytime there is a solo. We could bring in another guitarist or keys player but not every song has a lead which would mean for 70% of the time the guitarists would be doing the same thing! I'm new to effect pedals so I really am scrambling around in the dark, I was initially thinking an 'echo' pedal of some kind but i'm sure there is something more suitable.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm in a similar position in my new band which is a four piece (Drums, singer, guitar and bass), and I had this thought too. I decided in the end that the 'drop' you speak of actually goes a long way to emphasising the solo, and that I liked the way it change the dynamic of the song.

If you were set on filling it out though, I would say your best bet would be some form of tubey grit, to beef up your tone and spread out into the sonic emptyness.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

it's not just down to you, your drummer needs to be addressing it to. It's all about contrast, so if it sounds like it drops out from one section to another, he should play a smaller sounding cymbal in the previous section, and a bigger sounding cymbal in the empty section. IE if currently he switches from a crash in the chorus to a ride in the solo, he should instead swap the two around, or maybe go from crash to open hats.

I've always played in 3 peices. I've used a variety of different ways to fill space. Distortion is probably the most popular. Octave down or up can work. Playing chords works really well for me but can be difficult to get them to sound good (normlly sounds muddy). I use a dirty sound with loads of high mids when playing chords.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I love the sound of a 3 piece instruments, everything is generally clear and you all get your own space.
If you are playing Rock and Roll as opposed to 'rock', listen to Eddie cochran and buddy holly, very sparse. Also have a look at the stray cats, a modern take on rock and roll. Look at the drummers kit, a snare and and a high hat. No toms, try reversing what you are trying to do, get it simple. .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='bumnote' timestamp='1401467676' post='2463961']
I love the sound of a 3 piece instruments, everything is generally clear and you all get your own space.
If you are playing Rock and Roll as opposed to 'rock', listen to Eddie cochran and buddy holly, very sparse. Also have a look at the stray cats, a modern take on rock and roll. Look at the drummers kit, a snare and and a high hat. No toms, try reversing what you are trying to do, get it simple. .
[/quote]

Beat me to it with this ^. If it really is rock and roll, then the interplay between the instruments often carries the song. Oh, have a look at Carl Perkins

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maybe the guitarist is playing too much when he is not soloing and so losing too much when he drops it.

As for the bass:

Have a variant of the bass line for the instrumental section so instead of being empty it just sounds different - in fact instead of being the guitarist soloing, treat it as an instrumental section.

If you were playing quarter notes then play eighths, or vice versa.

If you were pedalling then walk, or vice versa.

If you were walking up then walk down, or vice versa.

But space is good. Most of us play more than is necessary.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Back in the early gigs, I did most with a fantastic guitarist. Loved his sound (think '80s metal). Learned a lot from him.
Back then, it was just my bass into combo. Nothing else.I was just playing riffs /root notes . We both always got complimented at our gigs.
Maybe keeping it simple is best.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey Darren - we've spoken on PM about this music. I think space is good & actually live doesn't notice in the way it does in rehearsal. I'm looking to move back to Wiltshire soon & have both a Gretsch and a J200 acoustic so if you do go down the 2nd guitar route give us a shout.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nothing will sound as bad as a band where everyone starts to overplay when the guitarist takes a solo, or the sound changes then changes back when he stops soloing.

Don't "fill in" all the spaces.

Spaces sound good. Leave them alone.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

IME, in terms of changing tone, adding a bit more gain/overdrive fills out the bass sound in the most musically pleasing way for rock, during a guitar solo in a 3 piece band.
A lot of it does depend on your guitarist though. My current guitarist is not quite as musically astute as others I have worked with and he is not good at "filling" his solo space, or using the best tones for the job (all IMO of course. I suspect he disagrees).
Other guitarists I've worked with knew how to "fill" a solo and it never needed me as the bassist to fill anything else while they soloed.
If it's just not working in a band situation though, sometimes it has to come down to song selection as some songs simply don't work as a 3 piece (with some guitarists) IMO.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='cheddatom' timestamp='1401439666' post='2463550']
it's not just down to you, your drummer needs to be addressing it to. [/quote]
[quote name='EssentialTension' timestamp='1401489965' post='2464286']
Maybe the guitarist is playing too much when he is not soloing and so losing too much when he drops it.
[/quote]

I've been thinking a bit about this thread since my last post and I think it *may* be more than this. A lot of soloing in the rock 'n' roll era involves thickening up the guitar with double stops or chord based soloing. It's easy for us as bass players to think we are the ones who are at fault but I wonder if your guy is doing a lot of single note soloing? Listen to Eddie Cochran or Buddy Holly - it's very heavily based around[b] not[/b] just playing single notes and that thickens the sound.

Just thinking about your playing from what you've said. In terms of the bass, jazzes are slightly better for cutting through the mix and playing more melody based basslines. A P-bass would thicken up the sound. And I assume you are using flatwounds, playing finger style nearer the neck? All this will make for a more authentic period correct sound. Effects weren't relied on then as they are now.

Failing on all that I was deadly serious in my offer to try out on 2nd guitar. And I see Rockabilly Rumble are playing the Vic on Friday 20th. I'll probably venture down to that one :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='BurritoBass' timestamp='1401724271' post='2466186']



I've been thinking a bit about this thread since my last post and I think it *may* be more than this. A lot of soloing in the rock 'n' roll era involves thickening up the guitar with double stops or chord based soloing. It's easy for us as bass players to think we are the ones who are at fault but I wonder if your guy is doing a lot of single note soloing? Listen to Eddie Cochran or Buddy Holly - it's very heavily based around[b] not[/b] just playing single notes and that thickens the sound.


Hi Burrito! Thanks for the replies, you were going to be my next port of call if I didn't get too many responses from this thread. I've had so many suggestions so i'm working through them one at a time, already spoken to my drummer to discuss his cymbal choices but that's reached a dead end, he seems reluctant to move away from the original recordings, so he wants to emulate what is being played rather than looking at what instruments we have and adjusting accordingly. My next step is effect pedals but I don't want to go down that route if i'm honest... My Jazz is roundwound stringed, i'm going to introduce my fretless with flats this week to see what that does for the sound but i'm hoping to use that for the real 50's songs and the jazz for ones that need a little more 'zing' (we cover modern stuff too, things that sound 50's) but if need be i'll play fretless all the time. Thanks for the offer of being second guitar, as long as you don't laugh at my bass playing you might have a deal!


Just thinking about your playing from what you've said. In terms of the bass, jazzes are slightly better for cutting through the mix and playing more melody based basslines. A P-bass would thicken up the sound. And I assume you are using flatwounds, playing finger style nearer the neck? All this will make for a more authentic period correct sound. Effects weren't relied on then as they are now.

Failing on all that I was deadly serious in my offer to try out on 2nd guitar. And I see Rockabilly Rumble are playing the Vic on Friday 20th. I'll probably venture down to that one :)
[/quote]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This weeks practice i'm going to cut back on what I play during the vocals and then do more during the breaks, walking lines and things, and see how it sounds...
Thanks for the advise and options chaps, i'll keep you posted and hopefully post a track or two so it's easier to see the problem...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...