Do you think of yourself as a musical 'artist'?

[Gank Bass]

I'm definitely borderline artistic, or at least on the artistic spectrum 

[Dood]

Tim Minchin said something about developing his brooding potential. 

[snorkie635]

2 minutes ago, Dood said:

Tim Minchin said something about developing his brooding potential. 

"I wish to make clear, this has nothing to do with me!"

 

[Man.about.Tyne]

Artist. Artiste, whatever..

 

Anyone can call themselves whatever they like and everyone else can laugh at them as they see fit.  If someone has made enough cold hard cash to laugh back then their status as an artist is considerably emboldened.

 

This does, however, lead to a considerable number of artists without much artistic merit.
 

[Owen]

An artist for me is someone who pursues expression within their chosen discipline. 

 

As a bassist I have never seen myself as an artist. I am a craftsman, and I like it.

 

I have recently started wrting and recording my own stuff. I never used to because I could not imagine anything I ever wrote comparing to Zawinul or Corinne BR or Floyd or Ben Folds (only the 5 iteration). I have recently made peace with the fact that the noise I make is the noise I make and none the worse for that. So part of me is exploring that artist side. I have just retired so the world better get ready for my Grey Vanity Project! The advantage of retiring is more time (apparently). The disadvantage is that I no longer have access to the beautifully equiped, ATC packing, control room at work. 

[Martin E]

People who rap all seem to call themselves artists.  

Great self belief always helps I suppose...

[Musicman666]

16 hours ago, SumOne said:

The general consensus/cliche is that musicians are artists - creative, expressing themselves, communicating emotions n'all that. But is that what you think of yourself? Seems a bit pretentious to me! 

 

Perhaps I've got no soul or artistry, but the more I play music and learn about it the more I think of it as a process, a technical skill. 

 

Is being in an orchestra and sight reading artistic? Is playing a cover version with some embellishments? Is even playing some sort of free-form Jazz? After all, even that is mostly about applying technical skill and music theory. Is making original music? Usually that seems to very heavily rely of pre-existing musical formulas. 

 

I think there are some musicians that are genuine 'artists', people that really do something original that transcends technical skill and know how, that's only a small % of musicians though. 

playing and creating new music influenced by music that i already like and primarily just to please myself ...is this art? .. i have no idea but I'm doing it constantly. Do a lot of home recording.

 

It definitely comes under the category of self expression but its expression back to myself... if i get paid or published for it then that's a bonus but that's not the prime reason. If i do a gig its for my own pleasure, definitely not for the money.

 

If i was the last guy on earth i would still be noodling on a bass as well as all my other gear....don't crave an audience.

Edited 15 hours ago by Musicman666