Grahambythesea

Having developed a really bad shoulder, my Fender Jazz 5 string started to really hurt after only 1/2 hour of playing. I'd mostly owned P. Basses over the years and never noticed the weight. I also had a semi hollow Gibson EB2 which was noticeably lighter, well it should be with most of the body being air! But it was not the best balanced bass I ever had. The issue has to be having a body heavy enough to stop neck dive without causing shoulder deformation! I bought the Spector Spectorcore 5 string which seems to be a happy compromise and would like to try the Lakland semi hollow to see how that "weighs in". Any one any experience of it? I am also considering an Epiphone Jack Cassady as one of the few truly semi hollow basses which are long scale, pity they don't offer a 5 string version or a 5 string Gibson Midtown. I really don't get the brigade that claim you need the body weight to get the sustain and tone. These are electric basses and with effects pedals, eq etc you can pretty much dial up any tone you want!

I think there is an advantage. You can play higher up the neck but still get those low notes, but the finger stretch is a lot less. When you are adapting from 25inch scale to 34 inch the fret spacing at the head end of the neck can feel an uncomfortably long stretch.

Glad your sale went okay. I have twice sold and once bought instruments where it was cash and we met in a car park. Scary. But each time I have met really nice people and had trouble free transactions. May be the musician fraternity is just a bit more honourable than the rest of the world!

Probably not your taste but Kyle Eastwood. Totally knockout bass player on fretless, fretted and upright and he has an amazing quintet.

When I had a Washburn ea35 I used rotosound black nylon strings which sounded great and not dissimilar to an upright, it was a fretless model.

GAK & Richtone both have them, I don't think they ae rare, they seem to come up on eBay quite often. I have played one and don't think they are anything out of the ordinary, if anything they are a bit prone to neck dive.

If you want to get away from the Jazz body shape but want a jazz pickup, then if you would settle for the P/J pickup set up check out Spector basses. Depending on the size of your budget the Korean made Legends are superb for the money but the Euro LX BASS would be perfect.

I returned to fretless playing via a Spector Spectorcore 5. Also needed a slightly lighter weighing bass due to shoulder problems and the semi hollowed body is a good hybrid, solid enough to give some punch, no feedback problems but not so heavy as a normal solid. The set up straight out of the box was superb (much better than my US Jazz 5 which cost twice as much).

Easyjet have a specific policy for instruments with maximum sizes mostly aimed at accommodating orchestral instruments. The case must not exceed 30cm x 120cm x 38cm. I expect that would include a kala u bass but it excludes most guitars. It will be classed as your one piece of hand luggage so no bag as well, they are pretty strict on this and if the overhead lockers are full they'll bounce your instrument into the hold!

I'm not the most computer savvy person on the planet and I mainly use an iPad, but try as I may I cannot figure a way of putting photos on her. Can someone enlighten me. Ta!

whoops pressed the submit button twice!

Fenton Weill Contra bass (weird angles on this but played ok) [Can someone tell me how to photos on here I'd love to show this strange beast?] No name cheapie short scale copy of a mustang bass Fender Musicmaster 72 Fender Precision (3 colour sunburst) Ibanez Roadster Fretless (maple neck) 96 Fender USA 5 string jazz (crimson burst) Fender USA Precision fretless (Olympic white) 66 Gibson EB2D (sunburst) Washburn EAB5 electro-acoustic 5 string fretless Spector Spectorcore 5 string fretless Just got the 5 string Jazz and the Spectorcore these days and a load of acoustic guitars, octave mandola and even a tenor banjo!

Keep the Lakland. You don't have to play the 5th, but who knows, you may find another gig when it will be really useful. Having occasional hand pains I have found it useful to use the 5th higher up the board to reduce the hand stretch and reduce discomfort.

Spector Spectorcore 5 string weighs in at under 8lb (3.6kg) and sits very comfortably. I guess the other choice may be Gibson Midtown bass. I used to own an EB2 which was very light and I guess the midtown would be similar. The ultimate option is an electro-acoustic, there seems to be hundreds on the market, but I'm yet to find one I like. I sold my Washburn 5 string e-a bass as the neck was awful! So wide. Aging bones and muscles seem to be a real problem for bass players, I suppose no one ever thought R 'n' R would last this long and those playing it might be drawing their pensions!

I'm really pleased with my Spector Spectorcore 5 string fretless. The EMG pickup is passive and then there's an active Fishman piezo bridge pickup. However it all works through the active eq. Normally about £800 bit shop around, I picked one up new from a store in Italy for under £500 delivered.

I think Pete Young may be right about scale length, 35 ins greatly helps the bottom B. I have two 5 strings, a US Fender with 34 in scale and a Korean Spector with 35 in scale and guess which is the better? Flat wounds could certainly help they generally have a higher tension than round wounds, but beware you will probably need to adjust the nut to accommodate the additional string width. I found Chromes had a high tension, in fact too much for me but it's all a matter of personal taste. The trouble is you may have to spend quite a lot trying different makes and gauges until you find one that suits. At an average of £40 a set this gets a bit expensive! Good luck.

Owned a single pick up Fretless Roadstar, lined maple neck, played superbly but not a lot of tone variation. I replaced it with a Fender P Fretless which did have a bit more punch. Both were bought second hand, the Ibanez for £99 the Fender for £650. Was the Fender worth the extra, probably not! Don't own either now.

You will find the short scale on both these guitars a bit of a contrast to the 34ins on your P bass, generally bass players consider the short scale to lack tone depth, but it is a matter of opinion. The Danelectro body is a curious laminate involving Masonite which some people describe as a form of cardboard. If the bass body adds to the resonance and tone of the instrument, and most of us think it does, then the Danelectro body is very low in resonance. Guild basses are generally well made but have never been popular, not only short scale and very narrow at the nut end, ok if you have small hands, otherwise quite uncomfortable. There's a reason why P & J basses have become the industry standard, Leo got it right and luthiers ever since and followed suit because it makes for good sounding instruments.

[quote name='mike313' timestamp='1444646103' post='2884681'] Thanks for the advice. Its not defretted, it is factory fretless, and it has the frets painted. [/quote] Are you sure about the "painted" bit? Fret lines on a fretless should be inset either wood or plastic. If they are painted they will rub off with wear from the strings. If it is fitted with round wound strings you will get a good zingy sound but the strings will cut into the finger board very quickly particularly on budget models where the wood quality isn't the best. Better quality basses fit ebony finger boards which are harder, wear less and sound better. I totally agree with the advice to try it unplugged and put your ear on the horn, the resonance is really important. Also ensure that the tuning pegs are smooth, if they are lumpy then tuning probably won't hold. This true of all basses fretted or fretless.Check the intonation, does the harmonic at the 12th sound the same as the note and make sure that when you play in the higher registers that it not fouling the board and therefore giving an untrue note. Sometimes people over adjust the action and put it too low. Conversely too high an action makes it difficult to play and notes will not be on pitch. This also applies to the nut at the top of the fingerboard. It should be cut a little lower than you would for a fretted bass but often they are not. The first couple of positions should be effortless to play. Personally I'd stick a set of flats on a.s.a.p but remember the gauges are usually a bit thicker than round wounds so the nut may need a bit of adjusting. Flats will not damage the fingerboard half as much as rounds. Good luck.

I got my Spector Spectorcore new for under £500 but you have to hunt for one. Brilliant quality but the Spector Performer 5 is readily available sub £400 one eBay. Spectors knock spots off Fenders and there cheaper subsidiaries - and I own both!

After years playing Ps I really wanted a 5 string and in 1996 Fender brought out the Jazz 5 and I had to have one. Bought the Crimson burst which is a nice colour which you don't often see but when it arrived it was set up so badly. The neck was set so low in the body there was no adjustment possible in the bridge. A little wage of cardboard did the trick, but for a US made instrument with a hefty price tag this was disappointing. I've still got it but it's never been the ultimate bass I expected it to be. It's also annoying that under some lights it hums, couldn't the guys at Fender come up with a decent humbucker for the Jazz?

I think we have technology to thank for this phenomenon! As commented above Fenders were designed to be mass produced but years ago "cheapies" were hacked out in dreadful factories by unskilled workers, but now computers can do much of the work so a factory in a developing world with low cost labour can make just as good an instrument as a skilled craftsman in the western world provided they a careful not to skimp on the quality of the materials. Often the frets let "cheapies" down, poor quality metal put in badly and not properly dressed. After all where are Squiers made these days. I have seen some horrors from that stable where the necks just keep bending, frets buzz etc. I once heard the Precision described as the electric plank and that probably sums it up. The same philosophy does not generally apply to acoustics though where the wood plays a much larger part.

Bass Collection do an excellent tribute to Jaco's Jazz with no scratch plate called the Portrait. Check out bass centre.com.

Surely a 32" low B would require a custom made string. I have 34 & 35" 5 strings and it is noticeable that the 34 has a much slacker B and thereby less tone than the 35"

I use chromes on a 35in scale 5 string fretless Spector and find them a little tight but I think that is the difference of scales. I have a 34in Fender Jazz 5 string which I think the B is a little slack on, but I have only ever tried wire wounds on it.