[quote name='Bilbo' timestamp='1333374540' post='1600723']
There is a difference between composing and arranging. If composer comes in with fully written charts with all the parts written out, you are playing his song. If someone brings in a sketch of a composed song and then everyone else chips in their own parts, you would expect a token royalty (main composer gets 40%, everyone else 5%). If it is brought in as a set of chords and the singer adds a melody, the bass player a middle eight and the drummer an istrumental break then it is more likely to be a band song with 4 even shares. But its all open to negotiation and legal challenge. Best sort it out before you write Bohemian Rhapsody: The Return.
In jazz, it used to be very common for agents or bandleaders to get a share of the royalties of songs they had no part whatsoever in writing. Its a difficult area and fraught with pitfalls.
[/quote]
This is pretty much how we play it - as a result, we have a lot of 'band' tracks; with a smattering of those brought in by individuals... the bulk of them from me, pleasingly
But yes, sometimes it can feel a little forced or pushy to be discussing credits when you're in the early days of a band - you've other things on your mind; you're having fun; you've no idea where it all might go... but it's best to get some form of agreement in place, good and early.
Pity you had such a divergence with the guitarist. I'm not sure entirely where it leaves you with him, but I think you'll want to get it nailed - I mean, you wouldn't want him swanning off and assuming your best material is his to do with as he pleases, if it genuinely isn't.