Dan Dare Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 Interesting conversation in the band the other day (no rows or fallings-out, but differing opinions). Thought I'd ask you lot. What should the policy be if someone makes a mistake whilst playing? It's inevitable that mistakes happen from time to time - the question is how to cope with/minimise them. In this case, our singer started another verse, rather than a chorus. I went with her, but a couple of the guys tried to stick to the arrangement. We rescued the situation, but had a discussion afterwards about what to do if it happened again. My thinking is that if one of the musicians makes a clam, the band should plough on and let them realise and correct (with a few pointed looks, etc to make them aware). Very few people in an audience are going to think "That bass player dropped a clanger" or "That guitar player got it wrong". Most aren't likely to be musicians and, crucially, the main focus is on the singer. However, if the singer makes a mistake and the band doesn't go with it and leaves him/her high and dry, people will think "the entire band screwed up". It makes sense to me that one should adapt on the fly in order to escape the situation gracefully and as unnoticeably as possible. Others felt the arrangement should be adhered to no matter what. What are your thoughts? 8 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Steve Browning Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 Generally, go with the singer (IMHO) if they make a mistake, otherwise plough on and let the miscreant find their way back (or stop playing!!). I wouldn't do the 'pointed look' as it will apparent to them that they've sphered it up and it alerts the audience to the fact. We might say that we played the jazz version when the number has finished. 4 3 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Muzz Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 Yep, always go with the singist, for better or worse...the disciplinary beating can be handed out after the gig... 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
fretmeister Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 Always go with the singer. It's annoying, but they are the focal point. 4 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lozz196 Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 Yep, follow the singer, I’ve seen band do otherwise and it ends up as a gangfurk. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
NancyJohnson Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 If it's me who makes a mistake (ie wrong notes), then I'll play the same thing again next time around. Beyond this, follow the singer. I think we're all of a certain standard, it's original material and we can just play through any issues. I doubt anyone out front really gives a toot. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hiram.k.hackenbacker Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 @Dan Dare you’re going to have to tell your band they are wrong. Follow where the singer is going. 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
musicbassman Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 Yes, always, always, follow the singer when it comes to arrangements getting messed up. But if they start off in the wrong key, then a car crash is pretty inevitable, as there's no undo button. Best to bring things to a halt, make a joke about it, and start again, and thoughts and prayers they'll get it right second time round. 😬 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
chris_b Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 Whatever the singer is doing is the song, so follow them. If individual musicians get it wrong then keep to the arrangement and let them catch up. 5 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dan Dare Posted June 12, 2023 Author Share Posted June 12, 2023 2 hours ago, Steve Browning said: I wouldn't do the 'pointed look' as it will apparent to them that they've sphered it up and it alerts the audience to the fact. I wasn't thinking of yelling "You plonker" and glaring. More a raised eyebrow kind of deal. 2 hours ago, hiram.k.hackenbacker said: you’re going to have to tell your band they are wrong. Only half of them felt differently to me and it wasn't a matter of life or death, fortunately. 1 hour ago, musicbassman said: But if they start off in the wrong key, then a car crash is pretty inevitable, as there's no undo button. The keys player always gives them a note if needed (say where there is no intro to lead them into it), so that hasn't happened yet, touch wood. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gjones Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 3 hours ago, Dan Dare said: However, if the singer makes a mistake and the band doesn't go with it and leaves him/her high and dry, people will think "the entire band screwed up". It makes sense to me that one should adapt on the fly in order to escape the situation gracefully and as unnoticeably as possible. I agree with you. I always go with the singer and if the whole band does it too, in many cases, nobody in the audience ever realises there was a mistake. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Franticsmurf Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 Everyone makes mistakes, it's how you deal with them that matters. Follow the singer as the rest of the audience will be and if you don't, they'll only notice you going wrong. It's good for the band to have something definite to do as well, as there is nothing worse than everyone doing something different as a reaction or the stubborn 'well it wasn't me' plough on regardless approach on stage. 3 hours ago, NancyJohnson said: If it's me who makes a mistake (ie wrong notes), then I'll play the same thing again next time around. Yes, me too (within reason). One of the bands I'm in has inexperienced musicians in the line up and I've told them if it doesn't clash too badly, repeat the mistake and own it. If it does, stop playing until you can come back in correctly as it's better to play nothing than notes/chords that clearly stand out as wrong. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Suburban Man Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 36 minutes ago, Franticsmurf said: Everyone makes mistakes, it's how you deal with them that matters. Follow the singer as the rest of the audience will be and if you don't, they'll only notice you going wrong. It's good for the band to have something definite to do as well, as there is nothing worse than everyone doing something different as a reaction or the stubborn 'well it wasn't me' plough on regardless approach on stage. Yes, me too (within reason). One of the bands I'm in has inexperienced musicians in the line up and I've told them if it doesn't clash too badly, repeat the mistake and own it. If it does, stop playing until you can come back in correctly as it's better to play nothing than notes/chords that clearly stand out as wrong. Rule One of Bass Playing - the correct note at the correct time. Rule Two - the 'wrong' note at the correct time is also permissible - who in the audience is going to know its wrong??? Rule Three - wrong note at the wrong time indicates that you need to find a new instrument to play Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rodders Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 Go with the singer if possible, keep your head up and make sure you're aware for any cues. If I make a big mistake then probably drop out for a bar (or next appropriate place) then drop back in. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
snorkie635 Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 Can someone explain what 'mistake' is please. Never come across this before? 😂 3 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
chris_b Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 Mistakes are fine. It's what you play next to turn them back into good notes that matters. 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Suburban Man Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 16 minutes ago, snorkie635 said: Can someone explain what 'mistake' is please. Never come across this before? 😂 Yeah, you're right. Rule Two - there is no Rule Two... 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Franticsmurf Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 22 minutes ago, snorkie635 said: Can someone explain what 'mistake' is please. Never come across this before? 😂 Ahh, you're an experimental progressive jazz player? Like me 🤣 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Franticsmurf Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 11 minutes ago, chris_b said: Mistakes are fine. It's what you play next to turn them back into good notes that matters. Yes, I completely agree. Mistakes are natural for all sorts of reasons. I'd add that it's also about what you do to minimise making the same mistake again in the future. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kitsto Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 (edited) Covers band I was in. Pub gig. Between sets singist/rhythm says to me (I was newbie): 'You're playing so many wrong notes.' Me (alarmed): 'Which ones? Which songs?' Singist/rhythm: 'Too many to mention.' Second set. Sharp Dressed Man. Crucial chord change mid-solo (which is quite long). Drummer (v experienced) has got into the habit of playing a little fill to warn me of the impending chord change. I've noticed that on this number in the past the singist/rhythm looks to my left hand to see when I change fret so he can change chord under the solo. Drummer plays fill. I turn my back so singist/rhythm can't see. Singist/rhythm completely lost. Train wreck. Band plays on. Lead guitar (excellent player) - still soloing - turns to singist/rhythm and shakes his head slowly and sadly. Made my night! Never criticised by singist/rhythm again. Edited June 12, 2023 by Kitsto 2 1 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Waddo Soqable Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 Just now, Kitsto said: Covers band I was in. Pub gig. Between sets singist/rhythm says to me (I was newbie): 'You're playing so many wrong notes.' I couldn't have resisted doing the Eric Morecambe, Andre "Preview" gag there...! 😁 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mcnach Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 7 hours ago, Dan Dare said: Interesting conversation in the band the other day (no rows or fallings-out, but differing opinions). Thought I'd ask you lot. What should the policy be if someone makes a mistake whilst playing? It's inevitable that mistakes happen from time to time - the question is how to cope with/minimise them. In this case, our singer started another verse, rather than a chorus. I went with her, but a couple of the guys tried to stick to the arrangement. We rescued the situation, but had a discussion afterwards about what to do if it happened again. My thinking is that if one of the musicians makes a clam, the band should plough on and let them realise and correct (with a few pointed looks, etc to make them aware). Very few people in an audience are going to think "That bass player dropped a clanger" or "That guitar player got it wrong". Most aren't likely to be musicians and, crucially, the main focus is on the singer. However, if the singer makes a mistake and the band doesn't go with it and leaves him/her high and dry, people will think "the entire band screwed up". It makes sense to me that one should adapt on the fly in order to escape the situation gracefully and as unnoticeably as possible. Others felt the arrangement should be adhered to no matter what. What are your thoughts? Same as you: people make mistakes, we carry on and let them catch up (with subtle or not so subtle hints, depending), but if the singer launches into the wrong bit, just follow them. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Norris Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 And if it's the guitarist soloing, follow the guitarist Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dan Dare Posted June 12, 2023 Author Share Posted June 12, 2023 1 hour ago, Norris said: And if it's the guitarist soloing, follow the guitarist Hmmm. One has to draw the line somewhere 😁 6 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
snorkie635 Posted June 12, 2023 Share Posted June 12, 2023 5 minutes ago, Dan Dare said: Hmmm. One has to draw the line somewhere 😁 The Pied Guitarist of Hamelin? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
.gif.9ad672bb8b84505709f76b39c8c256ec.gif)
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.