[quote name='jakesbass' post='257927' date='Aug 8 2008, 11:23 AM']I am undoubtedly turned off by perfection without an equal dollop of musicality in the mix. It's very rare to find both qualities in a player. If we are talking bass there are a handful of guys through history that make it for me.
In the wider world of music there are some notable examples especially in the classical world as despite the fact that they are regurgitating others creative output there is a massive emphasis on expression beyond technique in classical performance.
In Jazz the guys that really do it for me are the ones that have technical facility that make their musical thoughts appear effortless, instant access to their musical soul.
Wayne Shorter, Jaco (although I think he overdid it sometimes) Bill Evans, Miles, Oscar Peterson, Stan Getz, Kenny Wheeler, Louis Armstrong, Cannonball Adderly are just some of the guys that I listen to and hear what they are [i]saying[/i] rather than [i]what it is[/i] they are playing.[/quote]
I agree entirely about classical musicians.
Everyone seems to be equating "too good" with "too technical"- clearly there are players who have a massive technical facility, but IMHO being really good means much more than that. Is it possible to have too much technical facility? I would argue not, but its all in the use of that facility, and the expression that should go with it.