I go through this very same cycle.
At present with my gigging band it’s Precision - Sansamp - whatever amp I’m using, with a clip on tuner, ease of use/set up/break down etc.
For my classic rock band, as the studio has 810s I’ve put a compressor back in the line to tame the sound a tad, plus as the music is much more difficult a compressor helps me to be a bit more spot on. I also put a pedal tuner in as well.
I should add that there’s barely any compression going on, and hardly noticeable, it just tightens the sound up a touch.