[quote name='Buzz' post='395624' date='Jan 30 2009, 06:34 PM']Like I said, I'm happy for you that you're building something to your specs as that's always nice to see, and have I at any point said "stop, it's a bad idea"? I don't think so, but you very much came across as trying to sell us something in the OP.
I still think you've not given all the variables enough thought though.
I do hope it comes together for you though.
As to the rest of you who are trying to comdemn those members who are challenging the idea, I'd much rather be told my idea is flawed and has a good chance of turning out to not be what I'm expecting, along with the area's I need to rethink, than to be slapped on the back by a load of yes men who really wouldn't give two shits if it ended up being useless and costing me a fair bit of dosh and time. Shame on you methinks.[/quote]
The problem is not whether or not it will work it is all to do with the tone of what you are saying.
It has nothing to do with challenging the idea.
Groups of people who challenge ideas are generally called teams and can come up with great ideas if the original one has flaws.
You really need to think about how you word things-if I were to hear this spoken face to face in the tone that it looks like, I would be telling you where to get off cos you sound just like you're looking for an arguement.
I am well known for not being a 'yes' man