I didn't really rate Jason when I was younger, mainly as you couldn't really hear him... now I know it was a deliberate decision by the other members of Metallica, I'm left wondering. You can't watch Some Kind Of Monster and not think the rest of the band are pure dickheads, Hetfield leading the curve on that one, and that Jason had a point in getting out. The Justice For Jason stuff on Youtube is very good, and he works well with the songs.
Cliff I like, but am not wondering if it's just some sentimentality in there.
Rob is good, just not my cup of tea. We're all on here banging on about posture and he looks like he's squatting for a sh*t every time he gets on stage... just adds some comic appeal. He's probably the best of the three players, mind