I came up with an analogy the last time this subject came. Shortly after OTPJ gave me a complete roasting only to go out and by a RW!
[b]Jeans.[/b]
Do you wear faded, pre-distressed jeans? Are all your jeans dark, flawless and pressed with a nice crease? IMHO it's the same thing. It looks cool and it's fashionable. Nothing more to it.
It's not immoral, dishonest, ridiculous, stupid or any other term that is going to be used in this thread. It's a matter of taste, totally subjective and fairly trivial.
And FYI, I'm all for it. A good relic job looks cool, removes the first dink nerves, feels good to play and gives the vibe of a vintage instrument without the cost.