That's heavily scooped in the mids. Runs counter to getting a full rich sound in the midst of a band mix.
You won't be unhappy with a 2nd SM. To get proper happy you're going to have to EQ with your ears, with the band.
If the GK you're looking at has the usual GK scoop baked in you might like it with the knobs at noon. Actual neutral would be 10, 2, 1, 10 o'clock, bass to treble.