Interesting thread this. Gibsons have always been pretty unfashionable for many of the reasons discussed above, but I’ve gravitated towards “reverse” Gibsons over the years – they just seem to fit me ergonomically (I’ve got big hands, and can comfortably rest my right palm on the upper body bout), they’re proper “crafted” instruments, they always sound “big” which suits as I’ve normally played in trios until recently (yes, right amp seems to be more crucial than with a Fender – never sounded right to me through solid-state), and they look pure rock n’ roll – even the occasional dogs they’ve produced have always had style.
But their promotion/advertising division and variable quality control has always let them down hugely, basses way overpriced now - especially reissues of what were originally intended as mid-market instruments like the Ripper, and I would guess in terms of profitability that Epiphone are now much more successful?
Of all the Gibson designs, have to say I like the Victory least.