This reminds me of something my brother-in-law told me once. He is a huge Shadows fan and a regular visitor to a Shadows discussion group. One time they were arguing about what guitar Hank Marvin used to record a particular track, forget which now - was it the Strat or the Burns? Most people reckoned the Strat but one fellow said he had analysed the sound and it couldn't have possibly been a Strat because of x,y and z that appeared on the read out and therefore it could only have been the Burns. 'Jet' Harris, who was at the time an occasional poster said he was there when the recording was made and it was the Strat. They guy said, 'No, you are wrong, it was the Burns'. 😅