I was present when we tested my F112 against a BB2, Schroeder etc at the 2015 SEBassbash. What I heard against all the other cabinets reinforced and validated why it was such a great purchase. It was the smoothest and cleanest sounding cab...and this was from a good 12-15 rows back from the stage.
Point is, cab comparisons often rely on what someone is used to hearing both in terms of bass and amp. My context is a backline which is articulate and clean...faithful if you will. So I can plug in a range of basses and not find myself having to boost frequencies between instruments to hear myself. I've played through some backlines at Bassbashes and struggled to hear myself with all the woolly, unfocussed low end and lo-fi high end. If I had that at a gig, I'd be struggling. What I learned from that was different players are aiming for different things. Some want to immerse themselves in lo fi flub, others want pick attack to compete with guitars and yet others want the instrument and nothing but the instrument to shine through.
I think it's very important to tailor amp to bass. Some amps suck the midrange out like SWR SM400 and the Eden WT800. So playing mid scooped basses ends up in a situation where it's next to impossible to hear anything but tick and woof in the on stage mix...AND SOME GOSPEL PLAYERS like that. I would like to see how well they manage fretless though. However SWR amps sound great with mid rangey basses like Status or Modulus.
For a while I was playing Smiths and played them through one of the most aggressive, growliest rock amps out there, a GK RB700. The Smith was all about scooped mids, full (sometimes flabby) lows and mellow highs, the GK was all about pick attack and midrange. It sounded fantastic because they complimented each others shortcomings so well.