Im in a band with a couple of guys. The keys guy has departed a short while ago. The songs are funky rocky etc.
The original songs are ok ish but don't blow me away. The singer has a voice that has no control and he's an average guitarist but he does teach guitar. Hes a singer song writer who has (imo) no idea how to play funk. He just doesn't have that feel to his playing.
I suggested we try Vulfpeck's running away. What a great record.! He came to my house and it sounded ok. Then came the rehearsal. He suggested we down tune a semi tone to accommodate his voice. I kid you not he murdered it. Properly bad. The most shocking thing to me is that he couldn't hear it when I said it didn't sound good. Im not sure what chords he was playing. I know when music sounds good and that was not sounding good.
The awkward thing is I tried to like it generally and I've been quite enthusiastic thinking the songs might get better, tighter etc and have been with them for a while. So to let them down coming up to the summer when they are booking events I will probably come across like a total wombler.
I was so looking forward to playing live in the summer, but I just dont believe in the music. Maybe ive just answered my own conundrum.