I remember some time ago seeing some videos someone made with a Warwick Starbass fitted with a Tonestyler and that worked really well but like you said I think they were solo bass and not with any track
behind it. The P retro does sound like a great idea, did I read somewhere they stopped making it?
I suppose I’m just looking for ‘more’ from the P bass. I like the sound of it as it is now, I should have but didn’t check the tone pot value as it doesn’t have a huge affect on the sound when rotated either way. It certainly doesn’t add or subtract lots of high end like some passive basses I’ve had before so it maybe just that I need to change.
I think I suffer from ( whatever it’s called) the thing of if I’m playing a P bass I want it to occasionally sound more like a twin humbucking active bass and vice versa….. impossible I know and also why I have far too many basses.