Having owned the JC before, much prefer it for the classic smooth, woody, thump that people use P basses for, plus with flats it comes out even more so, the varitone I feel is more usable than actually turning the tone knob down, but that's just me,
Nice all round bass for the price.
Not tried the midtown bass so can't comment.
Only one semi acoustic I want and that's the dean cabbie bass.