I've always like CAR with an 'aged' scratchplate but I think it looks absolutely bloody awful with a plain white one. I had a look at mine last night Matt - particularly the neck wood and mine's not 'pasty' - it's about the same shade as a new Fender / 'Ray and it's got a very pleasant grain to it. The finish on the body is flawless, the neck joint is perfect, the components are top drawer and it has a very solid feel to it.
As you know Matt, I've had a few basses including several Laklands, Musicmen and Fenders, the finish on mine and this is as good as anything I've owned and although I loved it dearly, my departed Mex P (and it was a good one) just wasn't in the same league.
I guess the one you saw was a bad example.