[quote name='Clarky' post='1137699' date='Feb 22 2011, 08:47 PM']At the risk of turning this into some pseud-y argument over what is art, surely a good musician is someone who creates music that has the power to move you or stir some form of emotion. Joy Division did that (and still do) and Hooky was instrumental in that sound and the emotions they conveyed. Even the naysayers would (in many cases at least) have to agree that Hooky created some memorable bass lines - just listen to the clip of 24 hours I posted and tell me that is not a wonderful and original bass line that is central to a deeply moving song.[/quote]
Clarky, you speak the truth.
Joy Division and New Order are totally unique.
They have a style and sense of purpose that is roots based, chaotic, blase, industrial, post modern, arty, hedonistic... but it reflects the common man, non elitist.
They were post punk, were anything was possible.
Hooky is a hero of the bass and has launched 1000's of imitators.