I'm looking at the review of the Brazilian D'Alegria Dart Deluxe 5 string. (Issue 37)
It got a score of 2 out of 5 for value for money, that is average.
It costs £2981, it looks like it was made from a panel of an MFI wardrobe, the pickup cavities are embarrassingly too big for the size of the pickups, it has problems with the finish, there was a problem with the pick up pan control, the controls felt insubstantial and there was little tonal variation, according to the reviewer, Stuart Clayton.
There was a high degree of neck dive, the nut was cut badly, which on a 3K bass is totally unexceptable.
But Stuart awarded this £3000 bass, with all of these faults a 3 out of 5 for build quality, which equals a good score.
I would have awarded the following, cosidering the pric, 1 star for build quality, 2 for sound quality, as Stuart says it could give a good slap, finger, pick sound and 1 star for value for money. 1 star = poor, 2 stars = average.
Now, 2 pages before, there is a beautiful F Bass which is over £300 less, is a six string and is a thing of beauty.
I have a subscription the BGM and on the whole I like it. The reviews are well layed out with good quality, large photos of the products.
The interviews are a little tame and short and the amount of advertising is pretty reasonable compared to some publications.
I find with BGM that some editions are pretty good and then the next edition will go off the boil a little.
I would like to see reviews of the newer, Britsh bass builders, such as Shuker, ACG, Jim Fleeting.
I also think that a CD may be a good idea, with review samples, lessons and such, it may hike the price up but it is a bi-monthly publication, so I think it would make a less noticable difference to your pocket.