[quote name='bilbo230763' post='209687' date='May 30 2008, 03:27 PM']Chaka Khan's 'Ain't Nobody' (all beat and no groove),[/quote]
In my band we make it groove. In fact I think its got a pretty cool syncopated bass line. Certainly it's challenged the whole band in trying to play it cohesively. The bassline needs spot on timing though, which I don't always manage to nail if I play it when I'm tired.
[quote name='bilbo230763' post='209687' date='May 30 2008, 03:27 PM']This isn't about what the punters want. This is about doing the thing as superficially as possible and still getting away with it. Two rehearsals and you're gigging because you've all done it 1,000 times before.[/quote]
For us as a band, it's not about the music so much as its about providing a setting for the punters to enjoy themselves. We're not getting away with anything if the punters don't enjoy themselves. Last Saturday we had our crappiest gig ever, but the punters still had a good time although the whole wedding was appallingly organised. On Tuesday we had our best gig ever, the punters went mental - it was like being at a rock concert. Same set both times.
We've found the song choice is generally less critical so long as they hit the right mood. But its helpful to stick some new stuff in with the old stuff to broaden the appeal of our sets.