[quote name='chris_b' timestamp='1341233357' post='1715422']
And the assumption of the "amateur experts" that they know best because they read the book is an arrogance that I don't accept.
There you go. Denigrating the experience of others and belittling their opinions when you haven't heard them.
Snake oil comes at us from all directions, as it did when I was being told that mixed speaker sizes couldn't work.
[/quote]
I think you might have slightly misinterpreted what I was saying.
If someone's A/Bd different rigs & says "X" is better than "Y" because of "N", then their experience & advice is most likely going to be solid (I think that's the right word I'm looking for).
But if it's someone who's only ever used the same style of rig states that "I was told by X that you need a 4x10 & a 1x15" & have only ever used that, why would you take it as gospel?
I don't see where I denigrated anyone's experience. I've never said mixing speaker sizes doesn't work, only that it can be unpredictable.