I'm making the move to short scale after 20 years on the bigger boys. I find them just so much more comfortable to play, particularly over longer sets. Sound wise, there really isn't that much difference in newer models IMO, as modern preamps and modern string design can more than compensate for lower string tension etc. I have a Tanglewood TEB12 semi acoustic 30" bass. Tonally is very good and versatile, the only weak element being the E string which lacks definition compared to the other strings. But a bit of thoughtful playing gets around this. This is probably due to the strings I'm using more than anything else. I'm looking at a SX jazz bass next, and putting in a good preamp with good high tension strings should still deliver useable tone that most people would be hard pressed to tell the difference between it's 34" brother.