I have a passive p-bass and an active ATK310. I play in a band which deals in "classic" rock (Lizzy, Oasis, Beatles, The Who, Spencer Davis....I could go on...) and I play the P-bass exclusively because it just sits right in our set up. I'll tweak the tone control depending on the song, but most of the time it's rolled almost all the way off. I do love my ATK - it [i]feels[/i] right and sounds great on it's own, but does tend to get lost in the mix on most of our songs, so it's currently relegated as a back up, which is a shame as it's such a nice bass. I think I'm going to sell it and get another precision.