[quote name='mr zed' timestamp='1353601504' post='1876475']
Sorry chaps but you're all wrong. Has to be tort.
Edit: on second thoughts, I was wrong and you are right: Black.
[/quote]
Edit: on third thoughts, you were right the first time, but it depends on the exact colour of the butterscotch. The Squier CV '50s P in butterscotch blond, for example, does great with an all black pg indeed, but a picture search for butterscotch blonds with tort pg's shows some delicately coloured basses as well.
So, Mr. Undecisive, your problem is hereby solved: black or tort!
Anytime. Great to be of help.
best,
bert