I had a great e perience last Sunday, playing with saxophonist Gilad Atzmon. Gilad has a reputation for furious tempos and high energy playing and, although he was not nearly as intense as his reputation suggested, it was a roast. I was required to play some of the fastest tempos I have ever experienced but got through the night all but unscathed. Nevrrtheless, expecting the worst, I had brought my Wal and played the encore, Georgia On My Mind, using the electric.
Our usual drummer, who I have gigged with extensively and who has an enviable cv, was not on the gig due to back trouble but he was in the audience. He is very supportive of my electric playing but, for once, had the chance to listen from an audience perspective. His feedback was positive and included a comment I want carved on my gravestone! He said he couldn't hear much difference and that, like Steve Rodby, he heard only the music and not the change of instrument.
I have spent a lot of time thinking about the electric in Jazz and, to my ears, it rarely works. Steve Swallow has it covered and there are others but there are recordings by Jaco, Gary Willis and 100s of other fantastic electric players playing Jazz but it so often lacks the depth I associated with the bass in this music and sounds, errr, pingy. Its not about technique, there are plenty of monster tecnicians out there, but about tone in context. Most electric sounds don't work that well for Jazz.
What does everyone else think?