Interesting thread this. Having just read it in it's entirety (yeah I know I should get out more), it seems just to boil down to how the thing feels in your hands and the sound you prefer. I'm hardly qualified to comment owning a VMJ and a Squier P, but I have just ordered a Roger Waters P so it will be interesting to compare and contrast. I do think that the way a guitar is set up makes all the difference. I can get my P just the way I want it but for some reason I can't quite manage it with the VMJ.
Off topic, I was browsing in my local music shop today and saw a '73 Jazz all original, in fact it looked like it had never been played. Price, a cool £3,300!!! You'd hope it was one of the better made ones for that!
Beautiful bound fingerboard. One day...
LC