[quote name='BassTractor' timestamp='1381699870' post='2242679']
Yeah. Trying to be slightly less longwinded than I tend to be, I in fact worded it wrongly.
It reduces my joy when I loved the composition to begin with. It increases my joy when I disliked the composition.
BTW, I'm not talking about general knowledge of theory.
I'm talking about minute analysis of one composition - analysis that would involve writing out the whole composition by ear, then analysing it in its minute details, and writing down a reflection of that analysis.
The immense amount of time used on a composition this way, and later "hearing" not my joy but my remembrance of the analysis... that is what ruined it for me.
General knowledge of theory did augment my general appreciation for the work of a composer and for certain works, but appreciation is not the same as deep emotional experiences when hearing certain music.
I prefer that my ears just hear how great a piece is, rather than that an analysis tells me it is great.
[/quote]
Totally agree with the appreciation is not the same as the emotional experience. It's just I'm a bit of a nerd musically and i value the understanding on a intellectual level equally but totally different to the emotional experience.