I agree as it’s possible to have good and bad designs in most things.
I do think both designs up close have a different sound, maybe less so out front playing live.
It does make it harder making the best choice as we seldom have the opportunity to try at volume in a store etc.
I guess some of us also like mid punch less lows and others like low boom and fullness without so much mid growl or we want both depending on EQ etc
We have so much choice these days it’s a tough one choosing the right set up for a preferred sound and need