Jump to content
bassmansam

HX Stomp vs Preamp Pedal?

Recommended Posts

So I'm kind of in a dilemma with my live sound...
 
We're running IEM now and I'm strongly considering ditching head & cab. 
 
Ive been looking to add a nice preamp pedal to my chain and run direct to FOH... Mesa Subway di, Trickfish Minnow, Nordstrand Starlifter etc.
 
Ive recently also stumbled across the HX Stomp which looks like it could solve all of my problems in one simple solution. My only reservation is that I'll be disappointed with the effects and amp sims for bass. 
 
I don't use tons effects - Octave, Chrorus, Envelope and some compression. Definitely no fuzz or overdrive.
 
Does anyone else go direct to FOH? If so, do you prefer one of the above options?
 
Thanks 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't use a Helix, but an older HD500x as my pre-amp as well as effects. It is certainly more limited in respect of bass specific bass amp/cab sims, but it's still incredibly usable, and sounds great.

I would say that it does give you the ability to have a multitude of different variations on amp & cab sounds, useful for different songs, add in effects, and you can switch between effects and/or patches during songs / between songs etc. The only other comparable pre-amp that could do something similar would be either the SanaAmp BDDI Deluxe, or the VT Bass Deluxe (both of which are now discontinued).

A single pre-amp pedal would mean that you keep a "core" sound, and add additional effects to that. To vary your sound, you'd need to add another pre-amp or something like an EQ pedal.

Maybe take a look at the Helix LT, which would give you more connectivity options as well as switching options.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Being a sansamp purist for years I have just got my stomp.

 

You won't be disappointed.

 

Kept my bddi V2 mind, but yeah it nails the preamps

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Multi effects have so many options over and above a preamp. What I find odd is that in this day and age they aren't often made with a DI output. Throwing a passive box after the output isn't the worst thing to have to do, but I'd have thought that as we lean less on amps and even go in-ear, that these all-in-one mission control panels can't be plumbed straight into the desk.

Bizarre- but, yeah, I'd go multi.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There's always the new POD Go, same model set as the Helix range, but in a more versatile package than the HX Stomp and for around a similar price.

Some functions have been amended, but it would seem like a really good choice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

I use the HX Stomp in front of an amp when playing with a band, but I use it going direct when playing and recording at home. The amp models are excellent, and both the built-in cabs and the IR loader allow you a multitude of great cab options too.

And although I prefer to run it in front of an amp live, it's really nice to have the option to run direct if I need to for a fly gig, quiet stage, small bar setup etc. I'm really happy with it, both for effects and amps. The HX Stomp is also my entire setup for electric guitar (for recording at home) and acoustic guitar (for unplugged gigs), and I run direct in both those cases.

In terms of outputs - The HX Stomp technically has balanced outputs, so you can use a TRS to XLR cable to run to the desk without a DI box, but just for peace of mind and not having to carry a dedicated cable of undefined length I would use a DI box anyway.

Edited by Naigewron
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, Jus Lukin said:

Multi effects have so many options over and above a preamp. What I find odd is that in this day and age they aren't often made with a DI output. Throwing a passive box after the output isn't the worst thing to have to do, but I'd have thought that as we lean less on amps and even go in-ear, that these all-in-one mission control panels can't be plumbed straight into the desk.

Bizarre- but, yeah, I'd go multi.

In respect of the OPs query regarding the HX Stomp, that does provide a balanced out, albeit from a normal jack output rather than an XLR, which can go straight to the desk. (But you're right, a fair few don't). 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Al Krow said:

In respect of the OPs query regarding the HX Stomp, that does provide a balanced out, albeit from a normal jack output rather than an XLR, which can go straight to the desk. (But you're right, a fair few don't). 

That's good to know, thanks Al.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



  • Similar Content

    • By johnpaulbass
      Hello bass friends,
      I did a search before I decided to write down this thread. 
      I'm in a hunt, ONLY USED !, for a a good bass preamp that has to have the BAL input since for a future project we're working to go full in ear and this would be quite a minimalist thing (trio, mostly acoustic stuff, there will be some electric but with VEEEEEEEEEEERY low volume). I intend to build myself a pedal board with: tuner, preamp, maybe a LS2 from Boss in order to have the possibility of 2 basses.
      Said so I'm planning to use my Custom shop fender P bass and a semi hollow bass.
      So far, from what I have seen in this price range (again, in the used market) the choice goes between these:
       
      - Aguilar tone hammer (my favorite so far)
      - mxr m81 
      - electro harmonix battalion
      - eden wtdi
      ecc..
       
      The point of this thread is to explore for some other that I may not have found. What are you experience ? I would love to read of other preamps 

      Thank you in advance for your help.
       
    • By Baloney Balderdash
      Been working on my amp-less setup for a while (for my 4 string 28,6" scale Ibanez Mikro Bass, tuned to G1 standard tuning, as in 3 half steps above regular E standard 4 string bass tuning, equipped with a DiMarzio Model P P pickup wired directly to the output jack socket, and run through an always on 1 octave up effect mixed with clean signal, giving an effect similar to an 8 string "octave" bass with pairs of respectively bass and octave strings), and I think it finally has reached it's final form with the arrival of the Art Tube MP Project Series tube preamp that I ordered from Thomann last Friday night.
      I did however replace the "hand picked premium selected" ( ...yeah, right...  ) cheap Chinese stock tube, which had a prominent exquisite thin fizzy and harsh top tire Chinese premium crapiest of all crap tonal quality to it (which I suppose must have been the parameters Art instructed their official "tube hand-picker" in chief to aim for), with a proper quality Russian made EHX 12AX7EH preamp tube, which made a huge difference.
      So the tube in this preamp is definitely no cheap gimmick (don't quite understand the reasoning behind Art choosing to save a fairly minimal amount of production bucks by equipping this preamp with a horrible sounding tube from factory though, as it definitely doesn't give the customers the right impression of the overall actual quality of the unit).
      Though I am perfectly aware that this is in the cheaper end of tube preamps on the market, and that it utilizes a starved tube plate circuit, however I've read in a blog somewhere, written by someone who actually measured the tube plate voltage of this preamp, that it still runs at about 70V, which, while quite a bit more than most other starved tube circuits on the market, still is a long way up to the about 200 to 300V that, as far as I know, usually is considered the optimal plate voltage to run preamp tubes at.
      Non the less it does a great job at adding a really nice touch of rich warm tube flavor and slight compression, just taking the upmost sharp edge of my bass signal (not to be confused with tone sucking), sort of rounding off the harshness of my signal in a really beautiful way, while still retaining the bite and zing of it.
       
      This is how the Art Tube MP Project Series tube preamp looks :


       
      This is the specs sheet :

       
      And here's how my always on amp-less setup looks in it's entirety on written form :
      TC Electronic SpectraComp (always on, fully customizable, 3 band, compressor) ->> Boss LS-2 [A+B Mix <-> Bypass] (parallel effect loops mixer/switch) ->> ={  [Loop A Send] ->> [Loop A Return] ->||<- [Loop B Send] ->> Joyo Orange Juice (always on, relatively low gain, Orange amp style, overdrive, that is always mixed with the clean signal from parallel effects [Loop A] at an about 60% Orange Juice/40% clean signal ratio) ->>  [Loop B Return] }=>> Zoom G1 Four (exclusively used as an always on EQ, utilizing five 1 band fully parametric equalizers to fine tune the tone by boosting the 63Hz, 200Hz, 250Hz, 400Hz, and 1khz frequency bands +1 to +2 dB) ->> Behringer BEQ700 Bass Graphic Equalizer (always on, with the 50Hz, 120Hz, 400Hz, and 800Hz band boosted ever so slightly (~ +1 to +2 dB), and the 4.5kHz and 10kHz band cut repsectively about -5dB and -15dB) ->> Art Tube MP Project Series (tube preamp) 
      ->> [ Either : ->> headphones preamp ->> headphones (for home practice) /Or/ ->> mixer/poweramp ->> PA speaker/full range cabinet (for band rehearsals/jamming/gigging) ] 
       
    • By roceci
      Full working order, boxed with all gubbins included, works for bass or guitar. £80 posted to UK mainland.

    • By d_g
      Up for sale here is my John East J Retro. This thing sounds great and I'm only selling as I recently took this out of my Overwater and replaced it with a J Tone.
      Please note, my overwater has a separate battery box so the battery terminal is separate from the drop-in preamp (see pics) this means that a small amount of basic wire stripping and soldering is necessary to install the battery - hence the bargain price. The battery cables and ground cable are labelled to make it obvious!
      £125 posted in the UK.
      Any questions do let me know.
      Many thanks
      Dan
       





×
×
  • Create New...