Misdee

I don't know anything about the Tonerider, but the EMG and the DiMarzio are both eminently suitable. I would also include the Seymour Duncan Quarter Pounder as another out and out rocker worth listening to. The DiMarzio is the loudest and most aggressive and a classic in it's own right . I'm a big fan of that one. A bit of a left field choice maybe, but my favourite rock P Bass pickup is the Lakland NeoPunch. It's super hot, a bit dirty and compressed-sounding. I've also got a P Bass with the EMG Geezer pickup. It's a superb pickup, but not as aggressive-sounding as you might assume. I seem to remember that EMG actually tried to clone the pickup from Bobby Vega's 1964 Fender P Bass when they came up with the design. It's probably closer to the Fender CS 62 pickup than something like the DiMarzio. It's just a really good-sounding P pickup, but I wouldn't necessarily describe it as sounding modern. It'd be fine for any genre. Still plenty rock enough for most folks,though, I would expect.

Thanks chaps, yes, I've been watching exactly those YT demos. I've seen conflicting information about which model Gotohs to go for, that is partly why I was asking the question. I thought the GB640 might be the right one because it has four screw holes, not two like the GB528. I don't necessarily have absolute confidence in this Low End Lobster chap. He seems like a nice guy, but I wouldn't necessarily describe him as an expert in bass-related matters, let me put it that way. I will have to do some more research. Evidently the GB528 will definitely fit, so it's a safer bet. The last thing I need is to buy the wrong thing! There's nothing wrong with the tuning stability of the existing tuners, but I want to make the bass better balanced and lighter overall.

I recently bought a very nice Sire V5 bass that I want to upgrade by fitting lightweight tuners. I've been Googling and apparently the Gotoh GB640 Resolite Tuners are a direct retrofit. Is that really the case? If so, what I need to know is how difficult are they to fit, and what tools will I need ? I not very handy, but not completely useless either. Is it a fairly straightforward job to swap out the stock tuners for the Gotoh replacements, and what will I need to do it? Obviously , I know I'll need an appropriately sized screwdriver, but what about wrenches, pliers ect? For once I want to be well prepared for potential problems in advance. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.

I can't think of a question as such, but I would just like to say that Gail Ann Dorsey's first solo record, The Corporate World, that came out in 1988 was (and still is) one of the best bass albums of the 1980's. Her playing on that record is magnificent from start to finish. Inventive, clever, energetic and always tasteful. She's a gifted player, and a talented songwriter, too. I strongly recommend giving that album a listen if you haven't heard it yet. I'm a fan since I saw her on The Tube singing a Bobby Womack song and accompanying herself on the bass. I've always rated her, and it's not surprising she's gone on to have such an illustrious career.

I always thought the 5 string Sterling was a much more appealing shape than the Stingray 5, most notably the scratch plate. IIRC, the Sterling had different pickups,too. To me, a Stingray 4 with two pickups doesn't look right. A Sterling with two humbuckers is much better for my taste. I would definitely be interested in that. I wish I had bought a red one they had in Guitar Guitar a couple of years ago.

I remember reading something about the Sterling being revamped, presumably along the lines of Stingray Special. Seems like EBMM have put those plans on the back burner. I suspect that now they have introduced custom options for the Stingray Special, including a 38mm nut width, they might see that sufficient choice for their customers. Even so, it might be worth contacting EBMM customer services and asking them if anything is imminent for a reissued Sterling model. It was a very good bass with it's own appeal and it had some options that the Stingray Special still doesn't offer. A Sterling Special would be a very appealing prospect.

Felter Right Tw*t, overlooked and underrated bass player from the heyday of punk rock.

V1 or V2 are both fine. Some people prefer the V1. They crop up used fairly frequently because they have been so popular for a long time.

I put mine at the beginning, then a Diamond BC1 Bass Compressor. But I'm no expert with comes to pedals. I'm experimenting just like you. It might be worth contacting EBMM customer service and explaining your dilemma. The might have some recommendations on how to connect 18v bass to avoid overloading the input. It's probably going to involve some kind of a buffered input.

That's a difficult call to make. The Bongo seems a bit hotter, maybe because the mids are a bit more prominent than on a Stingray. The frequencies that tend to push the dial are there a bit more, maybe.

I totally get where you are coming from, but look at it this way; you could say the same thing about any amp and speaker cabinet you play through. The Bongo is such a good sounding bass that most preamps will compliment it well. I've got a Tech 21 BDDI V2 and it's one of the most coloured -sounding preamps on the market, but it's also one of the most useful in recreating the sound of a big amp and cabinet. It compliments most basses and styles of music pretty well if you take some time and experiment with it. It's also pretty reasonably priced. I mostly used to record my Bongo with a very old plugin of a vintage SVT combined with a studio compressor and it sounded terrific.

I've heard of other people having the same problem with the Bongo overloading their audio interface, it must be said. It's never been a problem for me recording my Bongo onto my computer, but I was using a very antiquated method via the headphones input of my PC via an archaic digital signal chain. I've got a new modern setup now, but must admit I haven't got round to trying the Bongo. Maybe the input level on the interface is tweakable? Or maybe going through a preamp before the interface might help.

It's been disheartening to sit and read so many people misrepresenting what I said about this girl and try to assassinate my character. Never let the facts get in the way of virtue-signalling. Some of you seem to be having a whale of a time. I wish I could take each and every one of you to task but I literally don't have the time, and besides which, it would be a bit of shame to spoil your fun. You really seem to have got the bit between your teeth. I would just like to reiterate that I never said that she couldn't play, I never said she played badly. I just said she wasn't a brilliant player. An endless queue of supplicants posting how "she plays better than me" doesn't make her so either. Like I said, she's pretty good, not great. Great is a high benchmark, though. Great is Marcus Miller level playing, or Jaco or Tony Levin. To be brilliant you have to be original, innovative. She's a capable player but there's nothing particularly new or original about her music. And as many folks have quite rightly pointed out, you don't have to be an outstanding musician to have a signature bass. Look at the Fender DeeDee Ramone P Bass, or the Nate Mendel.I could name lots more. Manufacturers just want to sell basses, I agree. But show me where I said this Tiger woman shouldn't have a signature bass and I'll buy one despite the fact I hate the colour scheme. Looking at it every day will be punishment in itself. On the subject of the actual bass, when she says "I want my bass to inspire and empower people to become their best selves" and similar twaddle I can't help but think "Have you ever bought a brand new Fender bass and experienced their legendary quality control? You would be better occupied hoping that their isn't a gaping 3mm gap between the neck pocket and the neck and that every note above the 15th fret doesn't choke." It would be lovely if Fender put out a YouTube video of their disappointed customers returning their defective purchases to the retailer for a refund or replacement. I've been there myself too many times. And if her looks haven't played a significant role in her being plucked from the chorus of internet bass players, what has? Do you really think her good looks are incidental to her burgeoning media profile? You are very naive if you do. I never criticised her for it, I never said she shouldn't do it. Like I said to begin with, that is the way of the world. But you shouldn't blame me for noticing. Somehow that is considered a heretical point of view when all I'm doing is stating the obvious. You are all so keen to pile on me and characterise me as a bitter old man, but that's only because you can only deal in stereotypes. You think because someone has a certain viewpoint they must be like the clichés you associate with those attitudes. It's the way you try and make sense of things you can't accommodate. It's a good job it's water off a duck's back to me, but some of you ought to be more tolerant of other people's opinions. I might disagree with some people's opinions on this subject, but I am not trying to make personal attacks on them because of their differing beliefs. The way some of you behave is tantamount to bullying. Someone else might not be so robust and take it to heart.

A point of view is a way of telling a story, an opinion is a belief or judgement about something. They are not mutually exclusive .

What am I supposed to be jealous of? You seem to be unable or unwilling to understand what I have posted, and what I have said is reasonable and rational. This is an example what psychologists nowadays call "projection". Your associate me with all sorts of things that in fact I have had nothing to do with it made any reference to. It's very disappointing but I suppose not that surprising that so many people are so outraged by a different point of view to the one which has been prescribed.

No I don't "dish it out". I am always polite and considered in what I post. Your just making things up now to suit your own narrative.

I don't respond to personal abuse. (Except by stating that I don't respond to personal abuse.) Then her parents have a lot to answer for.

I'm not that old.

Your clutching at straws now, aren't you? I'll spell her name how I like.

I really don't appreciate you or anyone else misrepresenting what I posted. I never said anything about "woke", or anything to do with that kind of thing. Not least of all because Fender making this signature bass is far from "woke". Put simply, the reason Fender have given this person their attention is because she is an a beautiful young woman, not because she is an exceptional or successful musician. Like I also said, there's nothing wrong with her bass playing, she's pretty good, but not exceptional. I only pointed out that there's nothing unusual about how or what she plays the bass, it's fairly typical. There's lots of similar players. I also pointed out that she hasn't had any mainstream commercial success with her music. That's demonstrably true. And I mentioned Marcus Miller as an example because he is a benchmark example of a truly exceptional musician who had a Fender signature bass. That's all I said, and I don't think there's anything contentious in that. The rest is everyone else projecting their own prejudices and preconceptions onto what I wrote. I can't be held responsible for that. Like I already said, if people enjoy Blue, her music and this bass then great. I never said she shouldn't have her own bass, I never said it was wrong. But it is what it is, let's not pretend otherwise. Ironically enough, if they offered this bass in a colour other than blue I might buy one. I really like the sound of the humbucker at the bridge, and lightweight is good for me nowadays. It's just that I don't like the colour.

Let's face it, it's not rocket science is it?

Well Justin died of an overdose, so I think he endured a crueler fate. There's worse things in life than being an estate agent.

Why do you assume that I should prioritise diversity and representation? It's your preference and preoccupation, not necessarily mine. You have no right to expect it should be so for everyone else.

Double post.

Like a lot of people nowadays, you automatically equate equality with virtue, and inequality with injustice.