[quote name='Clive Thorne' post='229959' date='Jun 30 2008, 07:23 PM']I suppose that what I'm really getting around to that if a 34" scale 4 string bass, drop tuned to a D on the Estring, still produces an acceptable E tone at the second fret, then why shouldn't a 32" scale bass, using the same string gauge produce an equally acceptable E on the open string?[/quote]
true, I drop my E string to D when a D or E flat is needed,
but I prefer the sound of the open E in standard tuning to the E at the 2nd fret in drop D tuning (and all other notes on the E string)-
more definition and clarity
the extra low notes in drop-tuning are at the expense of tone on the notes available in standard tuning on the E string.
which is why I like detuner devices to switch quickly- sometimes in the same song for only when the extra low notes are needed.