Jump to content
Why become a member? ×
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt

Fakes, Forgeries, Rip-offs & Counterfeiting


Bloodaxe
 Share

Recommended Posts

My take on the whole thing was that Turner seems to have very convincing provenance that what he has sitting in his studio is a genuine Ritter and if pushed I'm sure Ritter himself would happily confirm that. It all seems to hinge on the serial number. The one Turner has and the one in the music shop which is almost identical share the same serial number apparently. I say 'apparently' as the only evidence of this is supposedly someone made a quick visual check on the one being sold, I never actually saw a photo of the serial number on the 'fake' anywhere in the thread. However if we take on trust the two instruments do share the same SN then either something's gone wrong with the numbering system at Ritter or the one sold is dodgy. The music shop haven't done themselves any favours by selling it on pretty quickly after being contacted and warned that there could be some doubt over its authenticity.
I'm not sure about the market for knock-off high end intruments. Yes, there could potentially be a big mark up on each individual fake but it's a very niche market and in the internet age a higher risk of being found out as well.
Looks like the thread's been closed by the admin Turner now!

Edited by KevB
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Chris2112' post='1084297' date='Jan 10 2011, 10:54 AM']Yes, the thread is standard TB fare. The "inside types" remain cryptic, the vigilante martyr types reamin over the top in their "I will fight to the death to see justice done" stance and John Turner looks like a mug because of the whole sorry situation. At the moment, it's all a bit strange because Jens Ritter doesn't seem to have stated either way that the bass is real or fake. For all we know, JT could be holding the fake as the other bass looks better than his if I'm honest! If it's a mistake in the serial numbering of basses I wouldn't be surprised.[/quote]


seeing as i received the bass directly from jens at the namm show in 2005, i seriously doubt that. also, a quick visit to jens' site proves not only who is the owner of 443 but also the nature of the instrument (which is different, subtly, from the one at gc).

and as far as the gc bass looking better than mine, well i guess that's subjective, but the back of the neck of the gc bass doesn't look nearly as nice as mine, and i like the darker pickup covers on mine, but to be honest, the differences between the two are pretty minimal. like microscopic.

cheers :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

And therein lies the danger John. Like you, I would take one look at that "fake" and think it was a real Ritter, and a particularly nice one at that, with none of the over the top excess that spoils some of Ritter's other instruments. I can see why someone would be taken in by it. Hopefully Jens will chime in soon and clarify whether or not he did indeed make the bass.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just went over to the TradeTang website mentioned in that thread, and looked up bass guitars. Number one at the top of the list is a Ric copy with Rikenbacker made in usa on the headstock. Shameless lol!!
[url="http://www.tradetang.com/wholesale+rickenbacker_c220505.html"]TraadeTang chinese guitar making - copying place[/url]

Edited by daz
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Chris2112' post='1084590' date='Jan 10 2011, 06:18 PM']And therein lies the danger John. Like you, I would take one look at that "fake" and think it was a real Ritter, and a particularly nice one at that, with none of the over the top excess that spoils some of Ritter's other instruments. I can see why someone would be taken in by it. Hopefully Jens will chime in soon and clarify whether or not he did indeed make the bass.[/quote]

Jens did reply to the TBer who originally spotted the "fake" Ritter at GC and his email was posted on TB. TBH if you've ever had dealings with Jens (and I have), that email was 100% Jens. Here is an email I got from Jen's a few years ago when I pointed out that someone was copying one of his basses as a "tribute"

[quote name='Jens Ritter']Wow Mark!

That's strange! Thanks for Info! What should I do? I think he makes it for himself, right? I may just leave it like this. If he starts selling it, I need to intervene....[/quote]

That's pretty much the way Jens is by email. I think there is very little chance that the "fake" is anything but a visually accurate copy based on John's conversations with Jens and the email from Jens on the topic.

As for John looking like a "mug", I really don't see it myself. He has no control over this situation and has come off looking pretty reasonable.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Russ' post='1083812' date='Jan 10 2011, 12:47 AM']I've been in the same room as a well-known British luthier while he worked on making a very convincing fake late-50s Strat that a music shop owner that he was in cahoots with was intending to sell as genuine. And no, I'm not naming names.

Just saying, you don't just get counterfeiters in China. :)[/quote]
I have most of my 50's & 60's Fenders copied faithfully by a very experienced luthier,I do not do it to deceive ..I do it because I cannot justify the ludicrous cost of the original vintage item in a fine condition.
I also have additional marks added,parts altered or the model name altered to show they are copies so I personally will never try to sell them on as original.....that and that they are far to perfect...
I have originals but they are in the main refinished or in extremely poor condition.
Most Luthiers when pressed for a quid will undertake copies and lets face it the parts to make almost every conceivable cash cow are readily available from the states

65 Jag original but refinished
51 Esquire Modified model to Esquiresque,maker added to rear of headstock and,altered bridge to a Callaham the rest is 100% spot on

My 2 favourite guitars ...but I cannot justify ,let alone find a real 51 Esquire...so the copy suits my needs....You all know they are copies or refins Just like I do.

Copies are fine so long as we accept them for what they are and dont try to deceive others for gain

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Mark Latimour' post='1084599' date='Jan 10 2011, 06:26 PM']As for John looking like a "mug", I really don't see it myself. He has no control over this situation and has come off looking pretty reasonable.[/quote]

Mark, such a situation would be enough to make a mug of anyone, but especially so in the case when something extremely expensive which you own and initially thought was unique turns out to have an extremely convincing copy made of it. Someone has went to great effort here and has left John looking like a mug. It's definitely a proper mugging off, and would make a mug of the best men. Especially when it's out of your hands; as we see the bass has been sold and may never resurface!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='daz' post='1084594' date='Jan 10 2011, 06:22 PM']I just went over to the TradeTang website mentioned in that thread, and looked up bass guitars. Number one at the top of the list is a Ric copy with Rikenbacker made in usa on the headstock. Shameless lol!!
[url="http://www.tradetang.com/wholesale+rickenbacker_c220505.html"]TraadeTang chinese guitar making - copying place[/url][/quote]
Dont even bother with them UK border control possibly confiscate somewhere in the region of 95% of all their shipments to individuals,
HOW DO I KNOW THIS
We are contracted for the final destruction and incineration of these and other seized goods,UGGS, REEBOK,TOYS,PERFUME,DVDs etc etc every week container loads
And Cannabis by the van load.........And its all watched over by uniformed gaurds so DONT ASK!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Chris2112' post='1084607' date='Jan 10 2011, 06:37 PM']Mark, such a situation would be enough to make a mug of anyone, but especially so in the case when something extremely expensive which you own and initially thought was unique turns out to have an extremely convincing copy made of it. Someone has went to great effort here and has left John looking like a mug. It's definitely a proper mugging off, and would make a mug of the best men. Especially when it's out of your hands; as we see the bass has been sold and may never resurface![/quote]

Can't say I agree with you, but that's a long way to go to make a fairly inane point! :)

Edited by Mark Latimour
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Mark Latimour' post='1084619' date='Jan 10 2011, 06:46 PM']Can't say I agree with you, but that's a long way to go to make a fairly inane point! :)[/quote]

Why not be verbose when such wordiness is only a few keystrokes away! :)

Or to put a more Northern spin on things, you could say John has had his pants pulled down by this whole affair!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='tino' post='1084613' date='Jan 10 2011, 06:42 PM']Dont even bother with them UK border control possibly confiscate somewhere in the region of 95% of all their shipments to individuals,
HOW DO I KNOW THIS
We are contracted for the final destruction and incineration of these and other seized goods,UGGS, REEBOK,TOYS,PERFUME,DVDs etc etc every week container loads
And Cannabis by the van load.........And its all watched over by uniformed gaurds so DONT ASK!!![/quote]

If i was going to venture so far, id ask them to put some innane name on the headstock (Tokai seems to be a favourite) and get them to send the Rickenbacker plates via another post. Im sure that must be what happens anyway

[b]Tino[/b] Anyway never mind all that. Can i ask what that [i]great[/i] looking [i]51 Esquire Modified model to Esquiresque [/i] is? It looks fantastic

Edited by daz
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='daz' post='1084641' date='Jan 10 2011, 07:05 PM']If i was going to venture so far, id ask them to put some innane name on the headstock (Tokai seems to be a favourite) and get them to send the Rickenbacker plates via another post. Im sure that must be what happens anyway

[b]Tino[/b] Anyway never mind all that. Can i ask what that [i]great[/i] looking [i]51 Esquire Modified model to Esquiresque [/i] is? It looks fantastic[/quote]
The Esquiresque was built for me by local Bass Player & Luthier Martin Clark,for over 30 years I had been looking for a 51 and although in the 70s they were there to be bought I always found another use for the money.
For some 10 or more years I had a 52 neck that had been slaughtered a pair of 52/53 pickups from a caster??? and volume & tone pots from 54 and I ebayed ( sold out of auction)these....the funds realised paid for this to be built,the purchase of a 1943 Gretsch Hawaiin slide guitar from the states and theres a few bob left.

So if your in the market for a handbuilt bass ,,,,,built by a great fella and damned good bass player give Martin a call....tell him I said hello
I will hopefully be commissioning a telecaster bass to match the Esquiresque fairly soon ,if only the Gibsons would start selling :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Chris2112' post='1084628' date='Jan 10 2011, 06:52 PM']\Or to put a more Northern spin on things, you could say John has had his pants pulled down by this whole affair![/quote]

You could say that, but then it would just read like you were overly fixated by John's extended range instrument. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...