Hello,
- Please note I do not have the gear to make proper soundclips and tone comparison - This is purely subjective.
The difference between a rosewood and a maple neck has been discussed all over again.
I have always tended to prefer a maple board, with which I have a better feeling.
Yamaha is well known for its consistent build quality.
The Yamaha BB2024 and BB2024x series are particularly consistent from one to another.
I have spent ages searching for a maple board Yamaha BB2024MX, and have found one to compare with my BB2024 (now on sale, as the MX was quite pricey)
Specs :
The BB2024 weights 4.1kg
the BB2024Mx 4.1 to 4.2kg
Both happily built by same guy (m. Kobayashi)
Strings : both have new D'addario EXL160 nickel round wounds 50 . 70 . 85 . 105
I have tried to set them up as identically as possible, including the pickup height
Testing conditions :
I have compared them many times at low volume on a Phil Jones briefcase at home, a very clean and faithfull little amp.
I have spent a few hours playing both on a Fender TB1200 head with a 2x10 and 15 cab.
Feel :
The BB2024Mx seems to have more high mids and very deep lows, as if it was EQed a bit, with a little cut in the low mids
The BB2024 rosewood board feels like it has a more linear tone, but does not lack any of the overtones the Mx has.
I thought the rosewood grain did dim those a bit. It seems it does not.
Switching from one bass to the other - especially with the Precision pickup only, to which I am accustomed - they feel different.
The Mx maybe a bit brighter, more aggressive, and the rosewood has a little bit more of that big punchy hump in the low mids the Precision lovers do love.
Both are really similar, and the Mx is the one I prefer considering the looks, the fingerboard wood, and the rarity on the market, but the BB2024 with the rosewood fingerboard actually, and oddly, feels a bit better to me.
It may have something to do with the setup. Maybe the BB range was designed to be bright enough with a rosewood board, and is perfectly balanced like this. Maybe the difference is not related to the fretboard.
That is absolutely not a scientific approach.
I would have liked to have the gear or know someone locally to make a comparison video, but I will probably have to sell the 2024 beforehand.