[quote name='faceman' post='939667' date='Aug 29 2010, 10:47 PM']Not sure how much I'd agree with the pensioners playing In my opinion, the whole of Shine On is a pinnacle of human musical achievement. It moves me unlike another other piece I have ever heard. The feel, technique and skill is outstanding.
Waters' bass playing on records at least is ideal for the music. His tone is the classic pick-flats Precision tone. Have A Cigar is the best example from the top of my head![/quote]
When I said pensioners, I was making a tongue in cheek reference to how slow and delicate the music was. And I would be inclined to agree with you about the pinnacle of human musical achievement, had I not heard Gates of Delirium by Yes. But anyway, let's not send this off on a tangent.
Apparently Dave did play a lot of the bass parts when recording, as he could get them down in a lot less time then Roger (something we've yet to have Roger confirm himself, and like that would ever happen) - but listening to any live recordings, and you can hear he's competent enough for everyone to assume he played on the albums.