As a very general rule, I usually advise going up one 'gauge' for every half a step down tuned in order to maintain a similar feel and tension. Of course the 'perceived' tension may increase or decrease based on string thickness and how it feels under your fingers, but you can just about nail the actual, measurable tension.
Unless I've missed it, you don't say which gauge of string you are currently using that starts to feel a little loose.
I'll use as an example EXL170 on a 34 inch scale length.
Tuned to standard tuning:
1
G 2
0.0450 in.
42.52 lbs
2
D 2
0.0650 in.
47.89 lbs
3
A 1
0.0800 in.
39.59 lbs
4
E 1
0.1000 in.
34.07 lbs
EXL170 tuned down a half step
Gauge
Tension
0.0450 in.
37.88 lbs
0.0650 in.
42.67 lbs
0.0800 in.
35.27 lbs
0.1000 in.
30.35 lbs
So around a 5lb loss in tension, which is very noticeable.
In order to retain the same feel as EXL170 tuned half a step flat, these are the gauges the system reccommends:
Gauge
Tension
0.0480 in.
42.84 lbs
0.0700 in.
49.01 lbs
0.0850 in.
39.96 lbs
0.1060 in.
34.16 lb
Even using single strings (which you can buy) we don't actually make a gauge 106 or 48, so you are never going to get the exact same feel, using our strings at least. It's usually best to round up slightly so using single strings you could make a set of:
50 - 70 - 85 - 107
Of course buying single strings to make custom sets can get a little pricey.
So, if you want to by a predetermined set you have to compromise a little.
The compromise is only slight if you get the EXL160 set which consists of gauges: 50 - 70 - 85 - 105.
These will feel very similar to the EXL170 and won't take much adjusting to.
If you let me know the set of strings you are using I don't mind repeating the exercise to work out the best set for you
--
Adam.