[quote name='Bilbo' post='926602' date='Aug 16 2010, 03:57 PM']It doesn't swing, there is no internal logic to the lines and the sound sucks. Apart from that, its grrrrrreat....
If a player is playing a line in, say, A minor, it is not enough just to play the notes in an A minor scale. They need to start somewhere and go somewhere in a logical and musical way. THe logic is defined by strong notes (1, 3, 5, 6 or 7) and weak notes (2, 4) and by the creativ euse of chromatics (everything else) but just playing ABDCEF or G in any order is a bit crap.
When you are trying to swing, you need to get a sympathetic sound. The bass on Moondance is a kind of clunky ping ping ping ping ping that sits serparately in th emix and doesn't help the rest of the ensemble gel at all. His timing is also uncontrolled and fails to groove in any way whatsoever. The only good thing about this performance is that almost anyone with a pulse can improve upon it.
It is, of course, against the law to try....
If this sounds like a jazz walking bass line to you, I suggest you listen to anything with Ray Brown on it before you do anything else.[/quote]
Oh, dear
My band have just informed me I have to learn it!
Should I turn myself in now or after?
(and thanks for speeding the whole process up with the above, by the way, it means I have to listen to it less. Its just a HORRIBLE song! It DOTH suck indeed!)