[quote name='mcgraham' post='165911' date='Mar 29 2008, 03:46 PM']I played a 6 almost exclusively for a few years, 4 for a few (and still do), and a 5 (with a C) for a part of a year.
They are wonderful instruments but I'm with Jake, I just cannot get used to the sound of the C string. As soon as you jump onto that string on it's own the bottom drops out, and it often doesn't cut through (IME). However I enjoyed having the extra range and extra string for options. So the next bass I get will most definitely be a 5 and almost certainly strung with a low B.
In short I'd rather have more frets on the G to gain the range than an extra string so as to keep a better tone.
After saying that though, Janek Gwizdala plays with a high C on his bass; when he was playing with his band the bottom did not drop out at all and it sounded like a very natural extension of the instrument. Full and thick, or at least not so radically different from the G. I would hazard a guess to say that could be to do with the Fender TBP-1 preamp he has, which thickens up a bass tone wonderfully. Though I am not 100% confident he had it with him.
Mark[/quote]
I think it's a question of experimentation with different string types on your particular instrument. I've tried loads of different makes, and I totally agree that with some the C just doesn't sound right.
Elixirs are good, as are all of the DR strings, the C string on these sounds like it belongs.
As to why I play a 6, there are several reasons -
It feels comfortable to me, I have long skinny fingers and a 4 just doesn't feel right.
I like having the ability to play nice chord voicings, and let notes ring while playing other notes, really nice when a guitarist is soloing.
It makes reading easier, less position changes.
I play a lot of jazz, and it certainly makes playing through complex chord charts easier, again less position changes.
I also think it's more of a 'real' instrument, like a piano or a guitar.
On the downside though, I only have 6 string basses, no 4 or 5's, there are gigs that I'd like to do that I don't/wouldn't get offered due to peoples misguided stereotyping I suppose.