Jump to content
Why become a member? ×

TheLowDown

Member
  • Posts

    486
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by TheLowDown

  1. 17 hours ago, Baloney Balderdash said:

    Uhm?

     

    I don't agree (well except for the sound of P Bass being the archetypical electric bass guitar tone).

     

    If anything, as far as I am concerned, J Basses in general has a much more anonymous tone compared to the tone of a typical P Bass, which as far as I am concerned is full of character (and yes, I do love the sound of a P soloed as well).

     

    Ever heard The Stranglers, to name just one band where a P Bass has a quite central role, and definitely does a lot more than act as just a support for the other instrument and is quite precent in the mix...

     

    And it's not like even something as traditional and historically archetypical P Bass as James Jamerson's works exactly stays in the background either. 

     

    If anything a J Bass with both pickups full on is likely to get lost in the mix, unless slapped, because of it's inherent mid scoop.

     

    Also if you actually listen side by side to respectively a typical P Bass and a typical J neck pickup solo without any other instruments they will sound almost identical (given of course equipped with the same type/brand/model of strings and played through the same rig), the thing that will give the J away would be its somewhat more polished anonymous lack of character in comparison to the P with its somewhat more edgy tone full of character. 

     

    Of course, the P can play a central role such as in a lot of soul and rnb and reggae etc, when the music isn't busy. Sorry if I wasn't clear.

    With the J I have never been able to put it to any good use, whereas I view the P as more a plug and play bass that is either heard or felt. The bridge pickup may as well not be there, that bright nasal sounding tone that cuts through a busy mix is grating to me. When they are both on full, you're right, it disappears. When the neck pickup is on full and the bridge is off, you get something that tries to be a P but doesn't quite convince.

     

    • Like 1
  2. For me the P bass is the archetypal sound of the bass. The J and Stingray is probably better suited to situations where the bass needs to stand out("cut through") such as in slap based songs or in fusion, whereas the P is probably better suited where the bass is the supporting role. In most rock I would definitely pick the P.

    • Like 1
  3. 51 minutes ago, ped said:


    Yeah same but then again in a few years there’ll probably be a free alternative. 

    If it's free it will be ad based, I'm always happy to pay a reasonable one time fee to get rid of them. The thing is, subscription based is how most of them are going now.  Hopefully there won't become a time when we'll have to keep a database or spreadsheet of all our app subscriptions to keep track of them all to avoid continuous payment of apps we no longer use.

  4. If you set the metronome or drum track for a an exercise, and then consciously make an effort to play behind the beat or on the beat or ahead of the beat, then it will give you greater awareness of your own timing. 

×
×
  • Create New...