[quote name='katri' post='385685' date='Jan 20 2009, 01:07 AM']Would the EHX signal pad not do the same thing and cheaper.[/quote]
Nope, that's the thing I referred to earlier. The EHX SP is passive. The reason it's so cheap is that it's a potentiometer in a box. So if you roll it back, it's going to rub your signal in the same way your vol knob would.
If you like that sound, great. But if you want to cut your signal, and retain the same tone, you gotta stick a buffer in there. It's similar to taking a distortion pedal, say a DS-1 to use a generic example. You can turn the volume up and the distortion to 10 and hear it sounding nice and fuzzy. Now if you turn the vol. down on the pedal what happens? Nothing, it just gets quieter. The distortion doesn't lessen, the tone doesn't change, only the volume. Why, because its active and buffered for one. I'm oversimplifying here, but you get the idea.
[quote name='cheddatom' post='385701' date='Jan 20 2009, 01:54 AM']Yeh it would. The difference in tone could be down to impedance though couldn't it? Rather than volume.[/quote]
you could say impedance, but thats a big discussion. I'd say impedance is a big factor, so is the wood in the bass, so is the volume, so is the difference in strings, in the pickup type, on and on... again you get the idea.
breaking it down to real basics, the active has more output, plain and simple. the passive is a .22 rifle, the active is a 12 gauge. Why do some not like actives? because a .22 can kill your dinner, but a 12 gauge will kill it and shred it into little pieces.
in short, if we are only referring to my suggestion above, than no, the ehx won't work. For some other application you have? sure... I'm not claiming my way is the only "right" way.
hope this helps someone!
matt