I've never felt quite that strongly about it - most people (including myself at times) seem to get a kick out of engaging in mindless activity most of the time......so it's not really anything abnormal for crowds in some bar in some UK town on some Friday night to enjoy some Band with some cheesy singer playing some well known radio hits from the past.....and then go and go the same thing next weekend. I think it's a result of people generally having such depressing, unfulfilling jobs that they don't enjoy....any form of entertainment be it X Factor, Strictly Dancing, Corrie etc is a good distraction of the fact that they have to go back to hell on monday....
I really don't enjoy covers gigs. I do it in a part-time role (juggling with various bits of recordings work, teaching, original gigs etc) but have really cut back lately....I've less cash and wouldn't mind getting one or two weddings here and there for that extra £120ish boost but I don't regret at all sacking the whole "covers in pubs" thing.
I'm only 22/23 but after doing it quite alot throughout uni and the past couple of years it just depresses me. The buzz you get playing a set of songs you really believe in and have had creative input with, is a completely different thing to playing a set of the usual boring covers.
I really think that in this sphere of music there are two types of musician - those who technically excel and want to play covers (usually the boutique gear heads with marshall stacks, mesa boogie, ernie ball steve lukather guitars etc), and those who creatively excel and want to create their own material (gear freaks with obscure pedalboards, cheap japanese souped up strats, etc).
Often the boundaries between the two blur, for example king crimson (great technically/theoretically/musically as well as having that extra "depth" but really I'd rather be a part of the second group than the first. I know everyone has bills to pay and to be honest I know some great singer songwriters locally who might be a bit older than me, having a kid or whatever, and they have no choice but to play more covers gigs/get awful dayjobs in callcentres because they have the responsibility of a kid etc and need the cashflow to meet that. I'm just in the fortunate position of not having made such a leap yet.....who knows, if things change I may end up trying to love playing superstition and proud mary every weekend. jesus.....
dunno if any of that makes sense i wrote it on a whim hoho