[quote name='Shockwave' timestamp='1374868970' post='2154377']
Uhh, Many 5 strings are the exact same scale length (34") as 99% of 4 strings. As long as the 4 string has the correct gauge strings and setup, tonally there would be absoloutely no difference.
Pity, I am a very good player, live in London and I love your music. But at the moment I only have 4 strings. I do have a 6 and a 7 string fretless on the way, but because they have the same scale length as my 4's, "Tonally" They obviously cant hack it according to you.
Op I think you are misinformed and mistaken. This a site of well informed bass players who know probably a bit more about downtuning a bass more then your good self.
Of course, if its for other reasons such as "Image" then put that as your reasoning.
[/quote]
Your knowledge seems very good but when it comes to knowing my own music, no one knows it better. Believe me, I wrote it. I also played the bass on all of the tracks and I can safely say that without a 5 string bass, it would be physically impossible to play due to the extended range in some of the bass chords & high lead parts which sometimes sound like a 6-string guitar. I totally understand where you are coming from though.