Jump to content
Why become a member? ×

Recording band rehearsals with a portable recorder


Wilco
 Share

Recommended Posts

had a first go with my zoom h4n at last week's rehearsal and it captured everything, at listenable quality, I took it as a trial and just sat it next to my knee on top of a case, everything is audible and with better placement of it I'd be happy to use it for demo recordings, the bass is clear and deep, electric guitar is crisp, vocals are present and sound good (if distant but that's down to where the unit was sat).

I was just using the inbuilt stereo pair of mics too... :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Zoom devices are great for sticking in a corner and pressing play and forgetting all else bar the level.

If the band mix is ok... Zoom will deal with it well enough.
They have a very generous sweet spot for recording and the mic compresses
well enough.
If you have a screwed mix on these..your rehearsal mix would have been very poor anyway

For a plug n play device at their price point, I'd say they are pretty unbeatable.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You can pick up the mark 2 version of the Zoom H2 on evilbay pretty cheap. (comes packaged with the power supply, mini tripod, cables etc. I've used one for quite a while and find the sound quality is excellent. good enough to use on your band website or example. Has 4 mics so you can record in 'surround sound' or stereo . Gives you plenty of options for setting up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I used to have a Zoom H2N and got fed up with the interface/buttons. Found it was pretty unintuitive but it may just have been me. Sound quality was ok.

Sold it and bought an Olympus LS14 and I think its huge improvement. Particularly with the bass sound.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

+1 for the Zoom H4n. I've been using mine regularly for a couple of years now to record rehearsals & gigs, to capture ideas I have when I'm playing around at home (without having to fire up all the studio gear), and for work (recording radio interviews). Very dependable and versatile - there's a 4 track recorder with effects tucked away in there too.

Edited by Panamonte
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Another Zoom HN4 user. I record most rehearsals and a lot of our gigs with it. As others have said, what you get is down to how the band sounds, but actually I find that a good thing - it records what you actually sound like in the room! If you don't like it.....you know you have to change something.
For rehearsal recordings I use the mic stand attachment so I can put it where it works best from experience in our regular rehearsal room, and get good results every time.
Recording at the highest sample rate gives you about 3 hours, which is plenty. Combined with simple editing and labels via Audacity works for me to split it into tracks and convert to mp3.
Recording rehearsals is a great way to remember exactly what it was you all decided about tops and tails etc. but be prepared to invest some time editing, labelling and archiving if you want to get the best out of it. There's no point in having hours of recordings if you can't find what you want!
One thing - they eat batteries, so if you are recording something that's important to you and where you need to put it means you can't use the mains adapter, always use a fresh set, but this can get expensive.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Our keyboard player has a Zoom H4n and records all rehearsals, gigs etc. I always find the sound to be pretty good and rounded - the bass sound is usually very good - and the balance is good - if the band are balanced in the first place!

It has fallen off his keyboard a couple of times and has had one of its mics superglued back on, but it is still going strong.

He did say that he uses his with batteries only to save messing about with a PSU but it eats batteries, which may be a consideration.

Edited by Huge Hands
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've got a Zoom H2 as well, and have had it for over 7 years. Very versatile device - I've used it on low sensitivity to record band rehearsals, at which it performs admirably. It's bass response could be better, but I wouldn't be surprised if newer iterations improve upon that. I've also used it on medium sensitivity to capture close-up vocal work, and I'm very pleased with how it performs in that role too.

Minor complaints are:
[list]
[*]the hinge for the SD card slot trapdoor is weak, and has broken. This just means that there's no cover over the SD card slot, it still works fine.
[*]I've never been able to get it to work as a USB microphone - I get a lot of stuttering, and have never found out how to fix that. It just means that I'm constrained to recording onto the SD card and then transferring the files to my computer.
[*]User interface is a bit awkward. Again, I hope that newer versions have improved upon this.
[*]Battery life isn't spectacular - you get about 4 hours out of a pair of AA batteries. I recommend a decent stash of low-discharge rechargeables and a good charger to go with them.
[/list]

S.P.

Edited by Stylon Pilson
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Zoom H2n user here, and I'm very happy with the rehearsal recordings it picks up, including the bass. It accurately captures the PA and acoustic limitations of our rehearsal room ;)

Gain set to manual, gain wheel down to ZERO and it doesn't clip, but only just ;) Placement in the room is probably important (like don't sit it next to the drums).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ZOOM!

Why not record the performance too in glorious HD along with superb stereo sound? I've used the Q3HD for years - the Q4 and now the Q8. Love upgrading! The Q8 for example allows you to record on stereo mics and run a stereo line in feed as well as the video stream with the option of having all five media streams separate for editing later!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='JTUK' timestamp='1449825450' post='2927129']
Zoom devices are great for sticking in a corner and pressing play and forgetting all else bar the level.

If the band mix is ok... Zoom will deal with it well enough.
They have a very generous sweet spot for recording and the mic compresses
well enough.
If you have a screwed mix on these..your rehearsal mix would have been very poor anyway

For a plug n play device at their price point, I'd say they are pretty unbeatable.
[/quote]


what he said.

A bit of experimentation will allow you to find the best place to place the recorder, but you'll get a decent recording anywhere, really.
I use a Zoom H2. So many of our songs have come out of jams that were recorded in this little thing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Zoom H2 with the limiter set to Live 2 and you can't go wrong (at least I haven't. Never had any problems and can get very decent results out of it.

I believe there are some limitations if you rely on the battery - I recall some functions don't operate when it's being powered by the battery.

Edited by Bassman Steve
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm just so pleased with how the Zoom recorders pick up a stereo sound field! - With such clarity and don't distort like c@ppy 'phone microphones do.

A while ago, I very carefully recorded a thunder storm and for a laugh played it back on a separates cinema system with a nice big sub. Frankly, with the volume cranked, it was lie being outside again. Very impressive in the lows and crystal clear in the highs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...