Jump to content
Why become a member? ×

Choosing Songs for Your Band


BottomE
 Share

Recommended Posts

How do you choose the songs that you are going to learn, rehearse and ultimately gig?

Do you reach consensus or is there a dictator? What criteria do you factor in? Is it about the quality of the song or is it about the popularity and potential audience satisfaction?

An example i can give you is that our girl singer asked if we could have a go at a Bruno Mars song. On listening i can see why she suggested it as the line up suits the band, he sings like a girl and it appears to be very popular. However another member of the band says its only popular with 13 year old girls and it sounds like The Poilce :rolleyes:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In my present band we all have a veto.

Everyone must want (or at least agree) to play a song, whether it's a band original or a version of someone else's song, or we don't do it.

Before the veto is operated a discussion about and rehearsals of the song must take place - these can sometimes be fairly brief.

However, most decisions are straightforwardly unanimous.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='BottomE' timestamp='1358881446' post='1946546']
How do you choose the songs that you are going to learn, rehearse and ultimately gig?

Do you reach consensus or is there a dictator? What criteria do you factor in? Is it about the quality of the song or is it about the popularity and potential audience satisfaction?

An example i can give you is that our girl singer asked if we could have a go at a Bruno Mars song. On listening i can see why she suggested it as the line up suits the band, he sings like a girl and it appears to be very popular. However another member of the band says its only popular with 13 year old girls and it sounds like The Poilce :rolleyes:
[/quote]

Popular with 13 year old girls and sounds like The Police is supposed to be a negative thing ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Generally a democracy, but we all have a veto. Saying that the drummer and I are generally willing to give anything a go,but, the singer and the guitarist both vetoed a suggestion each of mine without even a discussion.

I vetoed out of hand their next 2 suggestions and really dug my heels in, the lesson wasn't lost and now, like Essential Tension's band, there is a discussion before it's vetoed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In my previous bands, one of us comes along with an idea (usually at rehearsal) & the rest of the band help write it, taking it home & working on their part & even contributing to other parts.

If it's a cover, someone would say something like "Have you heard XXX, think we could do a good cover of it?" Then we'd get the basics of the song & take it from there.

So a joint effort regardless of original or cover.

I'd take the Bruno Mars song & put your own take on it. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Choosing songs? Don't get me started on that one!
Too late!

I have two bands.
The first is a pub covers band. When we need new material, we run through a few suggestions on the iPod, and majority vote on which ones to do. Mine generally don't get chosen for some reason!
My other band is a 14 piece Blues Brothers act, so if we are staying true to the act, we only have a back catalogue of maybe 50 to choose from. However, adding a second set of similar genres is a little more tricky.
If we allowed all 14 to vote we'd never get anywhere, so we've appointed a committee headed of 5 to choose. In fairness, the others seem more than happy to follow.

I think song choices are possibly one of the biggest causes of bands splitting up. Apart from maybe sleeping with the guitarists wife that is?!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We all do what He bids. Otherwise we spend eternity in hell. Not exactly an ideal way to run a popular beat combo but apparently this is the way that He wants it run and I've been messed about so much in the past I'm ready to put up with anything.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In my main covers band, we fight like cat and dog over song choices we can never agree, being the most experienced musician in the band and the biggest prima donna if we can't do the song justice or the song doesn't do us justice I dig my heels in and refuse to learn it (we are a bunch of 45+ year olds playing rock, indie covers and I am afraid Moves Like Jagger just feels like peadophillia to me!)

In my second covers band either the guitarist or singer come up with an obscure suggestion from a successful band, usually a song no ones ever heard of but they seem to work pretty well when we gig them

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'll try anything but the rest want to just play stuff from the 90s and are frightened to tread outside the Oasis type material.

I try to explain you should play the stuff audiences generally want which is 60s,70s and 80s and yes some 90s and various genres within those eras, but generally get out voted :-(

But hey it's music and fun

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Our five piece band use Dropbox to share files, and on it we have a [b][i]Song Suggestion[/i][/b] list in [i]Excel[/i], where we add songs with the YouTube link beside them, and we all have a column where we cast our votes.

We have a choice of [b][i]Yes[/i][/b], [b][i]No[/i][/b] or [b][i]Maybe[/i][/b], if a song gets five [b][i]Yes's[/i][/b], then obviously it's in, if a song gets mainly [b][i]Yes's[/i][/b] and a couple of [b][i]M[/i][/b][b][i]aybe's[/i][/b] then it will be discussed, and any song with just ONE [b][i]No[/i][/b] will be binned, as we are playing for sheer enjoyment, and we don't want anyone in the band playing songs they don't like.

With millions of songs to choose from, there should never be a need to upset anyone in the band.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My current band we all select tracks we like, we all get veto if we don't like them. Singer gets ultimate veto if he can't sing them.

The other band I was in (past tense) we all picked tracks we liked and were thought suitable for the band and the singer would veto them because 'he knew what the audience wanted'. He now has his own choice of set list. And a new bass player.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Seems that you all have different approaches.

Some of the stuff my band mates suggest is bizarre. Being an unashamed whoring covers band i believe that we should play songs that are well known. Seems simple to me. We have had stuff suggested that you can't even find on YouTube! WTF. What is the point of playing things people won't recognise?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...